From: The Honorable Keith Ellison
Sent By: Abby.Schanfield@mail.house.gov
Help Encourage Healthy Housing & Housing Improvment
Supported by: The American Hospital Association, The Catholic Health Association, First Focus, and The Green & Healthy Homes Initiative
Please join us in asking the IRS help remove barriers to improving access to safe, stable housing and other preventive health initiatives.
In order to maintain their tax-exempt status, non-profit hospitals must show how they are contributing to a “community benefit” through hospital programs and projects. Hospitals are required to report these activities, along with other tax information, to the IRS through filling out the IRS Form 990 Schedule H.
Activities are reported in two parts. Part I addresses community benefit initiatives; Part II covers community building activities. The division of “community benefit” and “community building” activities into two different sections of Schedule H has left many hospitals unsure if housing-related projects can be considered a community benefit, rather than simply community building. This separation is proving to be a disincentive to taking on housing-related projects and other upstream activity.
There is significant evidence showing the connection between preventive health activities such as providing access to safe and stable housing, and positive health and economic outcomes. For example, for every dollar invested in lead poisoning prevention, taxpayers save up to $221. Additionally, the government saves up to $14 per every dollar spent on asthma deterrence.
In an effort to increase access to safe housing, we are asking the IRS to amend and clarify the Form 990 Schedule H, by combining the Community Benefit and Community Building sections of the Schedule H.
A simple modification of Form 990, Section H would clarify for hospitals that they can report housing improvements and other preventive health activities as community benefit and that the cost of those activities will count toward their total community benefit calculation. Moreover, with this change, both the community benefit and community activity must still address a documented need outlined in a hospital’s Community Health Needs Assessment.
If you would like to sign the letter, or if you have any additional questions, please contact Abby Schanfield in Congressman Ellison’s office or Nicole Cohen in Congressman Crowley’s office.
Keith Ellison Joe Crowley
Member of Congress Member of Congress
TEXT OF LETTER
Dear Commissioner Koskinen:
We are writing to request that the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) modify its Form 990 Schedule H, which is used by nonprofit hospitals to report their community benefits and other data related to tax-exemption. We ask that the IRS move Part II of the Form 990 Schedule H, which contains Community Building activity, into Part I, where hospitals account for Community Benefit activity. This modification would encourage evidence-based housing interventions and other activities that promote community health by allowing them to count as “community benefit” rather than “community building.”
According to recent public health reports, the physical environment in which an individual lives— in addition to socio-economic factors—may be responsible for up to 50 percent of an individual or community’s health outcomes. Moreover, public health experts believe that interventions targeting these determinants of health can be even more effective in improving the health of individuals and communities than clinical care alone. There is widespread consensus that affordable, healthy and safe housing in particular is essential for positive health outcomes. The reverse is also true: homelessness or unsafe and unhealthy housing can cause illness, aggravate chronic conditions and lead to lifelong health issues. The longer a child experiences homelessness or unsafe housing and the younger they are, the greater the cumulative toll of negative health outcomes on the child, family and community.
The clearest example of the relationship between poor health outcomes and inadequate housing is lead poisoning. Children from low-income communities and communities of color disproportionately live in distressed, older housing with a significant presence of lead-based paint hazards. As a result, they have increased rates of lead poisoning, which can result in behavioral problems; intellectual disabilities; barriers to academic success; and higher rates of incarceration. Childhood lead poisoning is estimated to result in an average lifetime earnings loss of $723,000 per child and $50.9 billion in lost economic productivity per year.
Poor housing can also cause or aggravate childhood asthma, which is the single most common chronic illness in children. In 2009, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation’s Commission to Build a Healthier America reported that approximately 40 percent of asthmatic episodes are caused by home-based environmental triggers. Further, the NIH Guidelines for the Diagnosis and Management of Asthma include the control of environmental factors. According to research, childhood asthma costs the United States health system $56 billion annually in direct costs and lost productivity.
We know how to address the physical and financial burden caused by unsafe housing and environmental hazards. Hospitals across the country, in partnership with public health agencies and community stakeholders, are working to address inadequate housing in their communities. These partnerships have created safe and affordable housing in at-risk neighborhoods; helped rid buildings of lead paint; and used creative strategies to eliminate asthma triggers from the homes of asthmatic children. Efforts like these provide more than just health benefits. For every dollar invested in lead poisoning prevention, taxpayers save up to $221.00. Moreover, the government saves up to $14.00 per every dollar spent on asthma deterrence.
Unfortunately, housing improvements and other upstream activities are not included as Community Benefits in Part I of the Form 990 Schedule H, but only in Part II, as Community Building. The delineation between Part I and Part II results in many hospitals being unsure if upstream activities can be considered a Community Benefit, which discourages hospitals from embarking on housing-related activities.
We urge the IRS to address this unintended consequence of the Form 990 Schedule H, and encourage hospitals to support housing improvements and other upstream health activities. The IRS should make community building activities a category under Community Benefit in Part I of the Form 990 Schedule H, which will make it clear to hospitals that they can report housing improvements and other upstream activities as community benefit and that the cost of these activities are counted in the total community benefit calculation. As with other community benefit activities, in order to be reported, these activities would be required to address a documented community health need and meet a community benefit objective.
Hospitals have the capacity to improve the health of their communities. This revision would remove a barrier that limits their ability to address the needs of their local community. Given the significant evidence about the connection between preventive health activities like safe housing and positive health and economic outcomes, the IRS should act quickly to amend and clarify the Form 990 Schedule H. As Congress continues to work to improve the health and well-being of all Americans, we look forward to hearing from you regarding the agency’s progress on modifying the Form 990 Schedule H.